One Encanto Song Secretly Reveals Mirabel’s Gift

One Encanto Song Secretly Reveals Mirabel’s Gift

Though it seems like Mirabel doesn’t get a gift in Disney’s Encanto, the opening song may subtly reveal Mirabel’s secret power all along.

Though it appears that Mirabel doesn’t get a gift in Encanto, the film’s opening song may subtly reveal the character’s true power. Mirabel Madrigal (Stephanie Beatriz) doesn’t seem to catch a break in Disney’s Encanto. Mirabel’s family members all get magical gifts from a miracle Abuela Alma (María Cecilia Botero) received on the night her husband died. For instance, Luisa (Jessica Darrow) and Isabela (Diane Guerrero), a.k.a. Mirabel’s sisters, get super strength and the ability to create flowers, respectively. However, Mirabel doesn’t receive a gift during her childhood ceremony, and the lack of powers strains her relationship with Alma. Of course, Mirabel’s lack of gifts ultimately motivates her to help her family when their magical house begins to crack, which has also spurred various Mirabel fan theories.


Encanto is full of tracks coming from the mind of Hamilton’s Lin-Manuel Miranda, and the animated musical is already experiencing unprecedented success. The earworm “We Don’t Talk About Bruno” has shot to number one on the Billboard Hot 100, five weeks after it debuted at No. 50. It’s Disney’s second song to reach that spot, following Aladdin’s “A Whole New World” in 1993. The entire soundtrack has also spent multiple weeks at the top of the Billboard 200 albums chart.

Related: Dolores Was Secretly The ‘Villain’ Of Encanto – Theory Explained

Mirabel’s lack of gifts defines her life, but Encanto’s opening song may change things. Mirabel kicks off Encanto by introducing her magical family in the opening song, “The Family Madrigal.” However, one lyric in the song is especially telling. Mirabel sings about her sisters during the song, saying, “The beauty and the brawn do no wrong.” A fan theory (via Reddit) points out that the only thing missing from that statement is the “brains.” Since Mirabel already had the brains to take over as the family leader after Abuela Alma, the miracle didn’t need to give her an additional gift.

Encanto’s Mirabel Has Always Had Her Gift

Three split images of Isabela, Luisa, And Mirabel from Encanto

The Encanto fan theory seems to fill in significant gaps in the film. Since Mirabel has two sisters representing beauty and brawn, it makes sense that her gift is brains/smarts. After all, having a female trio with beauty, brawn, and brains is a common trope in storytelling. However, Encanto puts a twist on it by not calling Mirabel the brains. Throughout Encanto, Mirabel has the nerve to figure out why the magical house is cracking, and she doesn’t need supernatural gifts to accomplish her goal. All she needs is her intelligence and determination, and she had that all along.

Encanto never thoroughly explains Mirabel’s lack of gifts. Though the end of the film reveals Mirabel as the future leader of the Madrigals, it’s unclear why she never received powers during her ceremony. Though Mirabel’s lack of gifts could be because she had brains all along, there are theories that Mirabel may have even sabotaged her own ceremony. Regardless, Mirabel will lead her family and her village into the future, and it’s reassuring that the Madrigals have the beauty, brains, and brawn to make that future whatever they choose.

Other Encanto Mirabel Fan Theories That Make Her Character Way Better

Mirabel lack of gift abuela mistakes Encanto

Encanto’s runaway success has resulted in various other Mirabel fan theories that not only make sense, but also give the character much more depth, and some theories are darker than others. For instance, one theory suggests that upon touching the doorknob, Mirabel unwittingly and instantly activated her gift: the power to bend and manipulate reality. Similar to Mirabel’s Aunt Pepa, whose control over the weather is dictated by her emotions, Mirabel’s fears about not getting a gift could have prompted everything and everyone around Mirabel to change with her perspective. In this dark Encanto Mirabel fan theory, the entire Madrigal family and the whole town are trapped in Mirabel’s fantastical nightmare-turned-reality, which also accounts for the musical aspect of the movie. Indeed, Casita cracking apart could’ve been a result of Mirabel seeing her cousin Camilo getting a gift after she presumably didn’t get one, which could’ve triggered Mirabel’s powers to go crazy. Curiously, this particular theory makes Encanto a child-friendly version of the MCU’s WandaVision, in which Scarlet Witch subconsciously controls the minds and assigns a made-up reality to the entire town of Westview.

Related: Encanto: Mirabel Did Get A Gift At Her Ceremony – Theory Explained

Meanwhile, another Encanto theory suggests that when Mirabel reaches for the door during the ceremony, the door didn’t disappear, but rather, it became the new front door to the Madrigal’s magical home. This theory is supported by several facts. During the ending of Encanto, Abuela Alma reveals that she asked Pedro for help and that Pedro responded by sending Mirabel. Moreover, Encanto ends with Mirabel’s image being carved onto the front door of Casita, which suggests that the very entrance to Casita was Mirabel’s all along. Indeed, despite having no apparent gifts, Mirabel is the one that Casita responds to the most. Whether or not these theories reveal the truth about Mirabel, what’s clear is that Encanto has managed to capture the imagination of its viewers, which bodes well for Disney’s possible plans to make Encanto 2.

More: Mirabel Accidentally Sabotaged Her Own Gift In Encanto – Theory Explained

HIMYM Theory Blitz Sixth Gang Member

How I Met Your Mother Theory Reveals A Secret Sixth Member Of The Gang

About The Author

Bill Bradley
(527 Articles Published)

Bill is an experienced reporter who’s covered entertainment and fandom since 2014. He’s done everything from unearthing the discarded Game of Thrones pilot script in a library in Texas to finding out why Steve left Blue’s Clues. He also enjoys eating Taco Bell and drinking chocolate milk.

More From Bill Bradley

Author: Deann Hawkins